Public data, updated November 19, 2026 Sources: NHTSA, EPA, AFDC

Comparison · EPA and NHTSA only

Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4

6 model years have an EPA range on both sides. In 2026, the longer EPA range is the Model Y at 357 miles. Lower kWh per 100 miles means the EPA test used less energy. Complaint counts are not divided by sales.

Year Model Y range ID.4 range Model Y kWh/100 ID.4 kWh/100 Model Y recalls ID.4 recalls Model Y complaints ID.4 complaints
2026 357 miles (Model Y Long Range RWD) 291 miles (ID.4) 24.3 29.8 8 2 463 3
2025 337 miles (Model Y Long Range RWD) 291 miles (ID.4 Pro) 26.9 29.8 3 2 118 32
2024 320 miles (Model Y Long Range RWD) 291 miles (ID.4 Pro) 28.0 29.8 5 9 340 54
2023 330 miles (Model Y Long Range AWD) 275 miles (ID.4 Pro) 27.5 31.5 17 14 1,204 476
2022 330 miles (Model Y Long Range AWD) 275 miles (ID.4 Pro) 26.0 32.0 20 7 886 137
2021 326 miles (Model Y Long Range AWD) 260 miles (ID.4 Pro) 26.0 34.0 23 11 1,105 342

How to read this

EPA range is a laboratory result for a full charge. It is not a promise of winter highway miles. A higher complaint count can mean more cars were sold, or that owners found the complaint form. Open the model-year page before you decide a number is good or bad. Recall totals here are campaign counts after duplicate numbers were removed.

Tesla Model Y overview · Volkswagen ID.4 overview

Sources: FuelEconomy.gov vehicles.csv and the NHTSA recalls and complaints APIs, snapshot 2026-11-19.